I actually have two questions. The first is dealing with
SBS2K and WinGate. Is this a good solution for a VPN or is
their something better? My next question has to do with
SBS2K3 with 1 NIC setup and a Linksys BEFVP41 VPN router.
Do I just setup the router and allow access to the LAN or
do I have to setup anything in SBS2K3? I figure that ISA
Server won't be a problem since I'm using the 1 NIC setup.
All recommendations are welcome, however, I must add that
the 1 NIC setup was the work of another consultant who
setup the wiring closet in such a way that I cannot safely
or even neatly implement a 2 NIC setup. I have informed
the client that this is not the recommended setup, but
their response is to work with what is available.

Thanks in advance,

MIke

Re: VPN Solution suggestions by TK

TK
Fri May 21 13:39:40 CDT 2004

Hello Mike,

A little off topic, since you arent dealing with EXACTLY this
scenerio .. but ...

I had no success with the LinkSys products and VPN. An MS technical
support person and myself finally troubleshot it down to Gre47 not
being allowed through the router. We contacted Linksys via a
conference call and the Linksys people kept telling us to forward port
47, to which both of us yelled at them that Gre47 has NOTHING to do
with port 47 .. however, that was the only response we got from
Linksys. My recommendation, go straight Cisco (probably cost you
something in the whereabouts of $1000 CDN) route.

FYI, I had read some documents about older versions of firmware
allowing Gre47 through, however, this was sometime ago and I did not
follow up with it.

Just my two cents worth ..

TK

On Fri, 21 May 2004 10:02:56 -0700, "MIke"
<anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

>I actually have two questions. The first is dealing with
>SBS2K and WinGate. Is this a good solution for a VPN or is
>their something better? My next question has to do with
>SBS2K3 with 1 NIC setup and a Linksys BEFVP41 VPN router.
>Do I just setup the router and allow access to the LAN or
>do I have to setup anything in SBS2K3? I figure that ISA
>Server won't be a problem since I'm using the 1 NIC setup.
>All recommendations are welcome, however, I must add that
>the 1 NIC setup was the work of another consultant who
>setup the wiring closet in such a way that I cannot safely
>or even neatly implement a 2 NIC setup. I have informed
>the client that this is not the recommended setup, but
>their response is to work with what is available.
>
>Thanks in advance,
>
>MIke


Re: VPN Solution suggestions by Merv

Merv
Fri May 21 15:02:32 CDT 2004

SBS2K + Wingate... Is there a reason that you can't implement the standard
MS PPTP VPN? If this is a 2 NIC setup...
http://www.smallbizserver.net/DesktopDefault.aspx?tabid=108

SBS2K3 with 1 NIC... I presume this is SBS2K3 Premium? With 1 NIC, you're
relying solely on the Linksys as a firewall and "defender of the LAN".
Would be better to have 2 NICs + the Linksys. What did the other consultant
do that's preventing you from putting a second NIC in the SBS?

--
Merv Porter [SBS MVP]
===================================
"MIke" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:104c901c43f55$76853d30$a001280a@phx.gbl...
> I actually have two questions. The first is dealing with
> SBS2K and WinGate. Is this a good solution for a VPN or is
> their something better? My next question has to do with
> SBS2K3 with 1 NIC setup and a Linksys BEFVP41 VPN router.
> Do I just setup the router and allow access to the LAN or
> do I have to setup anything in SBS2K3? I figure that ISA
> Server won't be a problem since I'm using the 1 NIC setup.
> All recommendations are welcome, however, I must add that
> the 1 NIC setup was the work of another consultant who
> setup the wiring closet in such a way that I cannot safely
> or even neatly implement a 2 NIC setup. I have informed
> the client that this is not the recommended setup, but
> their response is to work with what is available.
>
> Thanks in advance,
>
> MIke



Re: VPN Solution suggestions by SuperGumby

SuperGumby
Fri May 21 18:52:54 CDT 2004

Is WinGate already installed? (If so the guy that implemented it is a nut)

As the router is VPN capable (and a linksys to boot) getting it to do PPTP
passthrough may be a fiddle.

Me, I'd grab a nonVPN capable router, a second NIC, remove WinGate and
replace it with ISA.

"MIke" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:104c901c43f55$76853d30$a001280a@phx.gbl...
> I actually have two questions. The first is dealing with
> SBS2K and WinGate. Is this a good solution for a VPN or is
> their something better? My next question has to do with
> SBS2K3 with 1 NIC setup and a Linksys BEFVP41 VPN router.
> Do I just setup the router and allow access to the LAN or
> do I have to setup anything in SBS2K3? I figure that ISA
> Server won't be a problem since I'm using the 1 NIC setup.
> All recommendations are welcome, however, I must add that
> the 1 NIC setup was the work of another consultant who
> setup the wiring closet in such a way that I cannot safely
> or even neatly implement a 2 NIC setup. I have informed
> the client that this is not the recommended setup, but
> their response is to work with what is available.
>
> Thanks in advance,
>
> MIke



Re: VPN Solution suggestions by Jim

Jim
Sat May 22 15:19:36 CDT 2004

I have an account using a one nic SBS2000. For the upgrade to SBS2003
another cable is being pulled from the dsl router to the server. You
could even cheat a bit and install a cheap switch next to the SBS, add
a second nic, turn off dhcp on your router and set the internal ip
scheme to something other than the router ip. A big cheat because the
router is still on your network switch but with a different ip scheme
for SBS and workstations it might be slightly better.

With the Linksys all I ask of it is to make a connection to a dsl
modem, no firewall stuff expected. I set the SBS external nic as the
DMZ.


"MIke" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

>I actually have two questions. The first is dealing with
>SBS2K and WinGate. Is this a good solution for a VPN or is
>their something better? My next question has to do with
>SBS2K3 with 1 NIC setup and a Linksys BEFVP41 VPN router.
>Do I just setup the router and allow access to the LAN or
>do I have to setup anything in SBS2K3? I figure that ISA
>Server won't be a problem since I'm using the 1 NIC setup.
>All recommendations are welcome, however, I must add that
>the 1 NIC setup was the work of another consultant who
>setup the wiring closet in such a way that I cannot safely
>or even neatly implement a 2 NIC setup. I have informed
>the client that this is not the recommended setup, but
>their response is to work with what is available.
>
>Thanks in advance,
>
>MIke

Jim B. SBS MVP
remove the mvp to send email