I am currently rewiring the office (6E) and upgrading the wire closet so I am able to run at GB. The only server will be SBS 2003, 30 workstations, DSL line, ..

Is there any reason I should spend the extra and go with a managed switch? Am looking at the 3com Baseline 2824 and 3com Superstack3 3824.

Re: Managed Switch or not? by Mariette

Mariette
Fri Apr 30 11:36:21 CDT 2004

In news:99158DBA-5C56-4A49-9BC7-B369F624CCCD@microsoft.com,
John G. <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

> I am currently rewiring the office (6E) and upgrading the wire closet
> so I am able to run at GB. The only server will be SBS 2003, 30
> workstations, DSL line, ...
>
> Is there any reason I should spend the extra and go with a managed
> switch? Am looking at the 3com Baseline 2824 and 3com Superstack3
> 3824.

Definetly go for a managed switch!



Re: Managed Switch or not? by Mariette

Mariette
Fri Apr 30 12:16:21 CDT 2004

In news:36E10579-391E-42E1-A28B-92A2EB8FFD00@microsoft.com,
John G. <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

Could you expand a little on what the managed
> switch does for me? My elementary understanding is that it would
> allow me to monitor each port individually. Sounds helpful but for
> the cost I'm not sure it's worth it. Thank you again for replying.

A managed switch allows the ports on the switch to be configured, monitored,
enabled and disabled. Switch management can also gather information on a
variety of network parameters, such as ?

- The number of packets that pass through each of its ports
- What types of packets they are
- Whether the packets contain errors
- The number of collisions that have occurred

You should look for the following features on a managed switch
? Gigabit Ethernet support
- SNMP management and remote control capabilities
- A management interface that can be accessed through an internet browser
- Auto-negotiation support which auto-senses the speed and duplex
capabilities of connected devices
- Built-in expansion capability

Most important is that you can easily find where the problems are if large
amounts of collision occur in TCP/IP traffic

Bye
Mariette



Re: Managed Switch or not? by Kevin

Kevin
Fri Apr 30 12:53:20 CDT 2004

In other words, with an office of 30 workstations, a managed switch will
help assist you in identifying and resolving network issues easier than
simply runnnig to each of the 30 workstations, disconnecting them from the
network in order to determine which PC has the faulty NIC card that's
clogging up the bandwidth.

--
Kevin Weilbacher [SBS-MVP]
"The days pass by so quickly now, the nights are seldom long"



"John G." <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:36E10579-391E-42E1-A28B-92A2EB8FFD00@microsoft.com...
> Mariette,
>
> Thanks for the reply. Could you expand a little on what the managed
switch does for me? My elementary understanding is that it would allow me
to monitor each port individually. Sounds helpful but for the cost I'm not
sure it's worth it. Thank you again for replying.



Re: Managed Switch or not? by Jim

Jim
Fri Apr 30 18:53:16 CDT 2004

I have only used the managed features of a managed switch twice.
Recently to discover which workstations were streaming internet radio
frustrating the company owner. 256k internet is not a good speed for
internet radio when research is supposed to be done.

"Kevin Weilbacher" <kweilbacMVP@gte.net> wrote:

>In other words, with an office of 30 workstations, a managed switch will
>help assist you in identifying and resolving network issues easier than
>simply runnnig to each of the 30 workstations, disconnecting them from the
>network in order to determine which PC has the faulty NIC card that's
>clogging up the bandwidth.

Jim B. SBS MVP
remove the mvp to send email