Hi:

I own some Nokia stock and when it pays a dividend part
of it is withheld by my broker as "Foreign Tax Withheld"
The downloaded transaction shows up in the Investments
transactions as a transfer to the cash account as a
payment or credit. My broker statement shows it as a
debit to cash with is correct as I do not get the money.

When I try to balance I am off by the amount if the
transaction. Can anyone help me solve this?

Thanks
Ron

Re: Foreign Tax Withholding - can't balance by Dick

Dick
Tue Jul 13 08:29:58 CDT 2004

Seems like you'd need to add a transaction in the cash account expensing the
withheld amount.

"Ron" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:2b33c01c468ce$f841ccb0$a601280a@phx.gbl...
> I own some Nokia stock and when it pays a dividend part
> of it is withheld by my broker as "Foreign Tax Withheld"
> The downloaded transaction shows up in the Investments
> transactions as a transfer to the cash account as a
> payment or credit. My broker statement shows it as a
> debit to cash with is correct as I do not get the money.
>
> When I try to balance I am off by the amount if the
> transaction. Can anyone help me solve this?



Re: Foreign Tax Withholding - can't balance by via_newsgroup

via_newsgroup
Tue Jul 13 09:38:24 CDT 2004

In microsoft.public.money, Dick Watson wrote:

>Seems like you'd need to add a transaction in the cash account expensing the
>withheld amount.
>
>"Ron" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
>news:2b33c01c468ce$f841ccb0$a601280a@phx.gbl...
>> I own some Nokia stock and when it pays a dividend part
>> of it is withheld by my broker as "Foreign Tax Withheld"
>> The downloaded transaction shows up in the Investments
>> transactions as a transfer to the cash account as a
>> payment or credit. My broker statement shows it as a
>> debit to cash with is correct as I do not get the money.
>>
>> When I try to balance I am off by the amount if the
>> transaction. Can anyone help me solve this?
>

Just confirming, you get TWO transactions downloaded from your
broker for Nokia at each dividend time. One does contribute cash
that you see in the broker account and is about 85% of the total.
About 15% of the total come down as a separate dividend and shows as
cash in the Money cash account, but not on the broker's website.
That is what I think you are saying, and what I think Dick
understood.

A more complex alternative to Dick's method is to create a cash
account to hold withheld dividend money, and change the transfer
account for the appropriate dividends to that account. That would
allow you to track the dividend withholding. Then annually zero that
account with a transaction to represent the tax credit it becomes.
Dick's method is better for most people.


Re: Foreign Tax Withholding - can't balance by anonymous

anonymous
Tue Jul 13 10:06:00 CDT 2004

Thanks Guy's - I appreciate the quick response! - Ron
>-----Original Message-----
>In microsoft.public.money, Dick Watson wrote:
>
>>Seems like you'd need to add a transaction in the cash
account expensing the
>>withheld amount.
>>
>>"Ron" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in
message
>>news:2b33c01c468ce$f841ccb0$a601280a@phx.gbl...
>>> I own some Nokia stock and when it pays a dividend
part
>>> of it is withheld by my broker as "Foreign Tax
Withheld"
>>> The downloaded transaction shows up in the Investments
>>> transactions as a transfer to the cash account as a
>>> payment or credit. My broker statement shows it as a
>>> debit to cash with is correct as I do not get the
money.
>>>
>>> When I try to balance I am off by the amount if the
>>> transaction. Can anyone help me solve this?
>>
>
>Just confirming, you get TWO transactions downloaded
from your
>broker for Nokia at each dividend time. One does
contribute cash
>that you see in the broker account and is about 85% of
the total.
>About 15% of the total come down as a separate dividend
and shows as
>cash in the Money cash account, but not on the broker's
website.
>That is what I think you are saying, and what I think
Dick
>understood.
>
>A more complex alternative to Dick's method is to create
a cash
>account to hold withheld dividend money, and change the
transfer
>account for the appropriate dividends to that account.
That would
>allow you to track the dividend withholding. Then
annually zero that
>account with a transaction to represent the tax credit
it becomes.
>Dick's method is better for most people.
>
>.
>