Excel 2003 Read Only Error

I saved two files to a floppy from Excel 2003. Simply did a Save As command
and nothing else, not even changing the file name.

I took these files to two different machines, one running Excel 2000 and the
other Excel XP. Neither file would open. The error was Saved as Read Only.
I don't even know how to save a file as Read Only.

I brought the floppy back to the machine where the files were saved from.
Now, one file will open and the second gives me the same Read Only error as
I got on the other two machines.

Any hint as to what is going on?

Thanks....

Gord
Sat Oct 25 14:18:58 CDT 2003

Bishoop

Your first mistake was to save directly to a floppy. After that, you had
little chance of success.

Try to copy the file(s) to Hard Drive before opening.

Floppies are best used only to transport files from one computer to another.

Save the file(s) first to the Hard Drive. Copy to a floppy. Copy from the
floppy to the Hard Drive. Open the file(s) from there.

Hopefully you also saved them to your Hard Drive on your computer before
saving to floppy. The ones on the floppy may be unrecoverable.

Gord Dibben XL2002

On Sat, 25 Oct 2003 14:45:29 -0400, "Bishoop" <none@none.net> wrote:

>I saved two files to a floppy from Excel 2003. Simply did a Save As command
>and nothing else, not even changing the file name.
>
>I took these files to two different machines, one running Excel 2000 and the
>other Excel XP. Neither file would open. The error was Saved as Read Only.
>I don't even know how to save a file as Read Only.
>
>I brought the floppy back to the machine where the files were saved from.
>Now, one file will open and the second gives me the same Read Only error as
>I got on the other two machines.
>
>Any hint as to what is going on?
>
>Thanks....
>

Bishoop
Sat Oct 25 15:54:23 CDT 2003



Gord Dibben wrote:
|| Bishoop
||
|| Your first mistake was to save directly to a floppy. After that,
|| you had little chance of success.

Huh?

||
|| Try to copy the file(s) to Hard Drive before opening.

I copied the two from the floppy to the same PC they were created on. One
opens the other doesn't. Same results as trying to access them directly
from the floppy.

||
|| Floppies are best used only to transport files from one computer to
|| another.

Exactly what I was doing. There are other non-Excel files on the same
floppy that work just fine.


||
|| Save the file(s) first to the Hard Drive. Copy to a floppy. Copy
|| from the floppy to the Hard Drive. Open the file(s) from there.

Is this some unique routine for Excel? In many years of copying to floppies
I have never had this problem.


|| Hopefully you also saved them to your Hard Drive on your computer
|| before saving to floppy. The ones on the floppy may be
|| unrecoverable.


No problem, copies of the files are safely on the harddrive and accessible.


||
|| Gord Dibben XL2002

Thanks for your input.


||
|| On Sat, 25 Oct 2003 14:45:29 -0400, "Bishoop" <none@none.net> wrote:
||
||| I saved two files to a floppy from Excel 2003. Simply did a Save
||| As command and nothing else, not even changing the file name.
|||
||| I took these files to two different machines, one running Excel
||| 2000 and the other Excel XP. Neither file would open. The error
||| was Saved as Read Only. I don't even know how to save a file as
||| Read Only.
|||
||| I brought the floppy back to the machine where the files were saved
||| from. Now, one file will open and the second gives me the same Read
||| Only error as I got on the other two machines.
|||
||| Any hint as to what is going on?
|||
||| Thanks....

Bishoop
Sat Oct 25 15:57:02 CDT 2003



Gord Dibben wrote:


Just a side note. Dibben was my mother's maiden name. First I've run
across it except in the family (all in England) in 60+ years.

Dave
Sat Oct 25 21:23:56 CDT 2003

Floppies are notorious for losing data--It's not just excel, but all of office.
In fact, I don't save directly to a floppy using any program.

It's not the copying from/to a floppy that's bad. It's the direct opening in
any of the Office suite of programs that can cause trouble.



Bishoop wrote:
>
> Gord Dibben wrote:
> || Bishoop
> ||
> || Your first mistake was to save directly to a floppy. After that,
> || you had little chance of success.
>
> Huh?
>
> ||
> || Try to copy the file(s) to Hard Drive before opening.
>
> I copied the two from the floppy to the same PC they were created on. One
> opens the other doesn't. Same results as trying to access them directly
> from the floppy.
>
> ||
> || Floppies are best used only to transport files from one computer to
> || another.
>
> Exactly what I was doing. There are other non-Excel files on the same
> floppy that work just fine.
>
> ||
> || Save the file(s) first to the Hard Drive. Copy to a floppy. Copy
> || from the floppy to the Hard Drive. Open the file(s) from there.
>
> Is this some unique routine for Excel? In many years of copying to floppies
> I have never had this problem.
>
> || Hopefully you also saved them to your Hard Drive on your computer
> || before saving to floppy. The ones on the floppy may be
> || unrecoverable.
>
> No problem, copies of the files are safely on the harddrive and accessible.
>
> ||
> || Gord Dibben XL2002
>
> Thanks for your input.
>
> ||
> || On Sat, 25 Oct 2003 14:45:29 -0400, "Bishoop" <none@none.net> wrote:
> ||
> ||| I saved two files to a floppy from Excel 2003. Simply did a Save
> ||| As command and nothing else, not even changing the file name.
> |||
> ||| I took these files to two different machines, one running Excel
> ||| 2000 and the other Excel XP. Neither file would open. The error
> ||| was Saved as Read Only. I don't even know how to save a file as
> ||| Read Only.
> |||
> ||| I brought the floppy back to the machine where the files were saved
> ||| from. Now, one file will open and the second gives me the same Read
> ||| Only error as I got on the other two machines.
> |||
> ||| Any hint as to what is going on?
> |||
> ||| Thanks....

--

Dave Peterson
ec35720@msn.com

Gord
Sat Oct 25 22:37:45 CDT 2003

Bishoop

Below is a quote from your original posting.

> ||| I saved two files to a floppy from Excel 2003. Simply did a Save
>> ||| As command and nothing else, not even changing the file name.
>> |||

Below is a quote from your second posting.

> In many years of copying to floppies
> I have never had this problem.

Which was it? Saving to or copying to. Makes a big difference.

Gord
Gord Dibben XL2002

Bishoop
Sun Oct 26 08:16:40 CST 2003



Dave Peterson wrote:
|| Floppies are notorious for losing data--It's not just excel, but all
|| of office. In fact, I don't save directly to a floppy using any
|| program.
||
|| It's not the copying from/to a floppy that's bad. It's the direct
|| opening in any of the Office suite of programs that can cause
|| trouble.

Thanks for the input. I have never in the past concerned myself with saving
directly to floppies and never heard it was a problem til now. I guess I've
just been lucky.

This thread is really strange. First some with my mother's maiden name
(Dibben) replies and then you reply with the same last name as my father and
I. Of course Peterson is not rare but I have never ran across anyone with
the last name Dibben.

Thanks for the help.

Bishoop
Sun Oct 26 08:22:12 CST 2003



Gord Dibben wrote:
|| Bishoop
||
|| Below is a quote from your original posting.
||
|||||| I saved two files to a floppy from Excel 2003. Simply did a Save
||||||| As command and nothing else, not even changing the file name.
|||||||
||
|| Below is a quote from your second posting.
||
||| In many years of copying to floppies
||| I have never had this problem.
||
|| Which was it? Saving to or copying to. Makes a big difference.
||
|| Gord
|| Gord Dibben XL2002

In the instance where I was having the problem with the two files I had
Saved AS to the floppy.

In my second post I was eluding to the fact that I have never in the past
had problems either Saving To or Copying To a floppy.

So, with two guys telling me that there can be problems with "Saving To"
directly from an application to floppy I guess I'll confine my floppy
transports to files that have been "copied" from a previously saved file.

Thanks for the help.....

Dave
Sun Oct 26 08:24:06 CST 2003

Does that make you, Gord and me cousins?????

<vbg>

Bishoop wrote:
>
> Dave Peterson wrote:
> || Floppies are notorious for losing data--It's not just excel, but all
> || of office. In fact, I don't save directly to a floppy using any
> || program.
> ||
> || It's not the copying from/to a floppy that's bad. It's the direct
> || opening in any of the Office suite of programs that can cause
> || trouble.
>
> Thanks for the input. I have never in the past concerned myself with saving
> directly to floppies and never heard it was a problem til now. I guess I've
> just been lucky.
>
> This thread is really strange. First some with my mother's maiden name
> (Dibben) replies and then you reply with the same last name as my father and
> I. Of course Peterson is not rare but I have never ran across anyone with
> the last name Dibben.
>
> Thanks for the help.

--

Dave Peterson
ec35720@msn.com

Dave
Sun Oct 26 16:26:21 CST 2003

I think that this is a good rule to follow.



Bishoop wrote:
<<snipped>>
>
> So, with two guys telling me that there can be problems with "Saving To"
> directly from an application to floppy I guess I'll confine my floppy
> transports to files that have been "copied" from a previously saved file.
>
> Thanks for the help.....

--

Dave Peterson
ec35720@msn.com

amby
Tue Oct 28 04:20:38 CST 2003

hi all
remember the temp file that office creates and removes when you open the
application thats the problem
maybe the temp file could not be created and hence read only
hth
ambrish

--
www.simplesoftconsultants.com
"Bishoop" <none@none.net> wrote in message
news:#SLnLqzmDHA.3700@TK2MSFTNGP11.phx.gbl...
>
>
> Gord Dibben wrote:
>
>
> Just a side note. Dibben was my mother's maiden name. First I've run
> across it except in the family (all in England) in 60+ years.
>
>